The Engraved Argument: Eight Unique Watches, Eight Childhood Stories, and the Question Nobody Wants to Ask
Share
**At $188,000 apiece, these are not watches for reading in bed. They are watches for arguing about—specifically, whether a hand-engraved dial depicting Mowgli or Robinson Crusoe represents the pinnacle of artistic craft or the most expensive form of nostalgia ever strapped to a wrist.**
There is a moment, when you first see the engraving, that the watch stops being a watch. The dial plate of the LM Split Escapement is no longer white gold; it is a forest, a shipwreck, a sword fight frozen in metal. Eddy Jaquet, the Neuchatel engraver who spent years inscribing names on movement bridges before anyone thought to hand him a canvas, has turned eight stainless steel cases into miniature theaters of childhood memory. The novels are familiar—*Robinson Crusoe*, *The Three Musketeers*, *The Jungle Book*, *Moby Dick*, *Treasure Island*, *Robin Hood*, *The Last of the Mohicans*, *The Call of the Wild*. The execution is not. And the price, CHF 158,000 before tax, ensures that the conversation will never be simply about whether the engraving is beautiful. For anyone who follows how the independent watchmaking ecosystem—from the Custom Titanium Watches specialists to the ateliers that still employ human hands for tasks machines cannot touch—allocates value, this series is a test case in what craft is actually worth.
## The Object Beneath the Engraving
### A Movement Designed for a Canvas
The LM Split Escapement was not chosen at random. Its architecture places the balance wheel above the dial, suspended like a small mechanical planet, while the anchor and escape wheel hide beneath the baseplate. That arrangement leaves the dial plate—which is technically the movement's baseplate—unusually open. For Jaquet, it meant surface area. For MB&F, it meant an opportunity to let an artisan work at a scale that most watch dials do not permit.
The modifications required to accommodate the engravings were not cosmetic. The bezel was slimmed. The date and power-reserve subdials were openworked to expose more metal. The case dimensions were reworked, and a new crystal with a flatter dome had to be produced because the diameter had increased. The baseplate itself varies in thickness from 1.15mm to 0.35mm, which meant Jaquet was engraving into metal that could puncture if he pressed too deeply. This is not decoration applied to a finished product. It is a structural negotiation between an artist and an engine.
### Eight Stories, Eight Interpretations
The novels were chosen from a list of fifteen, with Jaquet given complete freedom in how to interpret them. His approach was not illustration but synthesis. In *The Three Musketeers*, ten figures engage in a sword fight so dense that a loupe is required to count them. In *Robinson Crusoe*, the power-reserve subdial becomes a telescopic view of a ship at sea. In *The Jungle Book*, Mowgli curls inside Rama's paws while the animals of the jungle keep watch. None of these images are borrowed from existing artwork. They are Jaquet's own reading, translated into relief.
Each watch comes with an original drawing signed by the engraver and a Loupe System X6 macro lens, an acknowledgment that the details are not meant to be seen at arm's length. This is a watch that requires an accessory to be fully appreciated. Whether that is a charming invitation or an admission of impracticality depends on your tolerance for such things.
## The Case for the Defense
### Craft as Its Own Category
The first argument in favor of this series is that it does something no machine can do. The OEM Watch Manufacturers that supply the vast majority of the watch industry can produce dials with extraordinary precision—sunburst finishes, galvanic colors, applied indices placed to tolerances that would have been unimaginable a generation ago. What they cannot produce is a scene. They cannot produce the specific depth of a sword fight engraved by hand into a surface that varies in thickness, by an artist who read the book and decided which moment mattered. The defenders of this series argue that the premium is not for the watch—the LM Split Escapement is a known quantity, and a standard version costs roughly half as much—but for the hours of skilled labor that no supply chain can replicate.
There is also the historical argument. Jaquet's first collaboration with MB&F, the 2020 Jules Verne series, won the GPHG Artistic Crafts Award in 2021 and sold out immediately. The market, in other words, has already voted on whether this kind of work deserves to exist at this price. The 2024 series is a sequel to a proven success, not a speculative experiment. The collectors who bought the Verne pieces were not confused about what they were buying. They were buying the closest thing the watch industry offers to a commissioned artwork that happens to tell time.
## The Skeptics Have a Point
### The Problem of Looking vs. Wearing
The counterargument begins with a simple observation: you cannot see the engraving while you are wearing the watch. The dial faces away from you. The details that justify the price—the tally marks on Crusoe's cross, the individual figures in the Musketeers melee—are invisible without removing the watch, finding a loupe, and holding it at the correct angle. A watch is worn on the wrist. If the primary value proposition is located on a surface that the wearer cannot observe during normal use, what exactly is being purchased? The skeptics argue that this is not a watch with an engraved dial but an engraving with a watch attached, and that the hierarchy is backwards.
There is also the question of legibility. The subdials are black against a white gold baseplate, which provides contrast, but the time-telling elements are secondary to the scene beneath them. The hours and minutes are indicated by hands that sweep across a jungle or a shipwreck, and reading the time requires the eye to separate signal from story. This is not a fatal flaw—many artistic watches sacrifice legibility for beauty—but it is a trade-off, and the skeptics argue that at this price, trade-offs should be acknowledged rather than romanticized.
### The Suspense Neither Side Resolves
Here is the question that hangs over the series: is hand-engraving at this level a living craft or a luxury fetish? The defenders point to Jaquet's skill, the years of training, the GPHG award, the sold-out predecessor. The skeptics point to the fact that the engraving is invisible during wear, that the watch is functionally identical to a model costing half as much, and that the eight unique pieces will almost certainly spend more time in safes than on wrists. Both are describing the same object. The disagreement is about what the object is *for*. Is it a watch that happens to be art, or art that happens to tell time? The answer determines whether the price is justified or absurd, and no specification sheet can settle it.
## What the Series Says About the Industry
Strip away the literary references and the engraving debate, and the 2024 series is also a statement about where MB&F sees itself. The brand built its reputation on maximalist machines—the HM series with its orbiting balances and alien geometries—before the Legacy Machine line introduced a more classical vocabulary. The Eddy Jaquet collaborations push that classical turn further, toward a kind of watchmaking that values the hand over the mechanism, the image over the indication. Whether that is a maturation or a retreat depends on what you wanted MB&F to be in the first place.
The eight pieces also sit at a strange intersection of the market. They are stainless steel, which is unusual for watches at this price—most competitors at CHF 158,000 are gold or platinum. The choice of steel is deliberate, a signal that the value is in the engraving rather than the case material. But it also makes the watches look, at a glance, like something more affordable. The Custom Rose Gold Watches that occupy similar price brackets announce their expense from across the room. These do not. They announce their expense only when you look closely, which is either the point or the problem, depending entirely on your relationship with understatement.
## The Verdict That Refuses to Arrive
The MB&F × Eddy Jaquet LM Split Escapement 2024 series is not a watch for everyone. It is not even a watch for most people who can afford it. It is a watch for the collector who has already owned the obvious things and wants something that cannot be compared, because there is nothing else like it. The engraving is genuinely extraordinary. The movement is genuinely excellent. The price is genuinely high. None of these facts resolve the argument, because the argument is not about facts. It is about whether craft, divorced from daily utility and visible only under magnification, still counts as value. Jaquet's answer is yes. The skeptics' answer is no. The eight owners will cast their votes with their wallets, and the rest of us will continue to argue about what those votes mean.