The Two-Faced Tribute: When a Reissue Forgets What It Was Reissuing

 

**One is black, matte, and honest about its origins. The other is blue-grey, sunray-brushed, and dressed in fauxtina. They share a name, a case diameter, and a story about a Mercury astronaut. They do not share a soul—and the argument over which one actually honors the past has become more interesting than the watches themselves.**

There is a particular trap that awaits every reissue. The first attempt is usually made by people who remember the original, or at least remember why it mattered. The second attempt is made by people who remember the first attempt, and who have spent the intervening years reading what the internet said about it. The result is a watch that is technically superior, historically more informed, and somehow less convincing. The two generations of the First Omega in Space sit on either side of that trap. The 2012 original was a straightforward proposition: a 39.7mm Speedmaster with straight lugs, a black dial, a calibre 1861, and a tribute to Wally Schirra's personal CK 2998 worn on the Mercury-Atlas 8 mission in October 1962 [citation:6]. It was not perfect. The caseback was a bit plain. The tachymeter bezel lacked the "dot over ninety" that vintage purists cared about. But it was coherent. It knew what it was. The 2024 generation is a different animal entirely. It has the dot over ninety. It has a stepped dial, a hesalite-like sapphire crystal, a METAS-certified calibre 3861, and a colour-shifting grey-blue surface that Omega says replicates the tone of certain vintage CK 2998s [citation:8][citation:9]. It is, by almost every measurable standard, the better watch. And yet, the question that has divided collectors since its release is not whether it is better, but whether better is the same thing as right. For anyone who follows how the Custom Titanium Watches tier of the industry approaches heritage, the two FOiS generations offer a case study in the difference between fidelity and fluency.

## The Objects, Side by Side

### The First Generation: Honest, If Imperfect

The 2012 FOiS was not trying to be a vintage watch. It was trying to be a modern watch that looked like a vintage watch, which is a different thing. The case measured 39.7mm across, with the straight lugs and symmetrical profile of the pre-Professional Speedmasters. It was 14mm thick, which is not slim, and the crystal was sapphire, which meant it had the "milky ring" effect that sapphire Speedmasters of that era carried—a pale halo around the edge of the glass that never quite disappeared [citation:14]. The dial was black, matte, and legible. The hands were Alpha-shaped, polished, without lume. The movement was the 1861, a descendant of the calibre that went to the Moon, with 48 hours of power reserve and a reputation for reliability that bordered on the boring [citation:2]. It was not a numbered edition, but it was understood to be a tribute, and it sold steadily without ever becoming a phenomenon.

The caseback carried the Seahorse medallion and the inscription "The First Omega in Space, October 3, 1962" [citation:6]. That was the extent of the storytelling. There was no fauxtina, no colour-shifting dial, no attempt to simulate the imperfections of a sixty-year-old object. The watch trusted the wearer to know the history, or to look it up.
Custom Turquoise Watch Dials

### The Second Generation: Fluent in the Language, Uncertain of the Accent

The 2024 FOiS shares almost nothing with its predecessor beyond the dimensions. The diameter is still 39.7mm, but the thickness has dropped to 13.4mm, and the lug-to-lug is 48mm [citation:8]. The case has been reshaped, with a less angled lateral bevel and a crown and pushers that are closer in style to the original CK 2998. The bezel insert now carries the "dot over ninety" and the "diagonal 70," small details that matter enormously to the people who care about such things [citation:8]. The crystal is the most talked-about element: a sapphire that has been shaped to mimic the domed profile of hesalite, eliminating the milky ring while retaining the visual warmth of acrylic. Omega has even laser-engraved the Omega logo in the centre of the crystal, an Easter egg that rewards close looking [citation:5].

The dial is where the arguments begin. It is a grey-blue sunray, produced through chemical vapour deposition, and it shifts from nearly black to a muted blue depending on the light [citation:4]. Omega says this replicates the colour of certain vintage CK 2998 dials that had faded or aged in unpredictable ways. The hour markers and hands are filled with a vintage-toned Super-LumiNova that reads as light orange or amber, a deliberate simulation of aged radium . The subdials are bowl-shaped and sunken, the hour markers are elongated, and the Omega logo is applied in a vintage font [citation:8].

The movement is the calibre 3861, a co-axial Master Chronometer with a silicon balance spring, 15,000-gauss magnetic resistance, a 50-hour power reserve, and a five-year warranty [citation:3]. It is objectively superior to the 1861 in every measurable way. It also has a stop-seconds mechanism, which the 1861 lacked, and which some purists regard as a betrayal of the hand-wound Speedmaster ethos.

## The Case for the Second Generation

### Technical Superiority as a Form of Respect

The first argument in favor of the new FOiS is that it is simply a better watch, and that better is not a dirty word. The 3861 movement is more accurate, more resistant to magnetism, and more durable than the 1861. The hesalite-like sapphire crystal solves a problem that plagued sapphire Speedmasters for years without sacrificing scratch resistance. The bracelet, a flat-link design borrowed from the Calibre 321 Ed White, features Omega's comfort release adjustment system and is widely regarded as one of the best bracelets the brand makes [citation:5]. The caseback is double-stepped and more historically relevant, with discreet engravings that replace the numbered edition of the original [citation:8].

The defenders also argue that the aesthetic choices are not arbitrary. The grey-blue dial, the fauxtina, the stepped profile—these are attempts to capture something that the first generation did not attempt. The CK 2998 was not a uniform object. The dials varied. The lume aged differently. The watches that survived in collections often looked nothing like the catalog photographs. The new FOiS is not simulating decay; it is simulating *variation*, the individuality that made each vintage Speedmaster slightly distinct. Whether that is a worthy goal is a matter of taste, but it is not a cynical one.

## The Case for the First Generation

### Restraint as a Historical Virtue

The counterargument begins with the observation that the first FOiS was honest in a way the second is not. The 2012 watch did not pretend to be vintage. It was a modern watch with vintage proportions, and it made no apologies for its sapphire crystal or its lack of fauxtina. The black dial was not an attempt to replicate a specific faded CK 2998; it was a black dial, chosen because black dials are legible and because the original CK 2998 had one. The hands had no lume because the original hands had no lume, or because Omega decided that lume was unnecessary, or because the design simply worked without it. There was no calculation behind the choices. There was just a watch.

The sceptics argue that the second generation is trying too hard. The combination of a colour-shifting dial and amber fauxtina is, in the words of one commentator, "a bit too much" [citation:13]. The original CK 2998 was not meant to look like this. Some examples may have aged into these tones, but to replicate the accidents of time in a new watch is to misunderstand what makes vintage objects compelling. A faded dial is beautiful because it earned its fade. A new dial that simulates fading is wearing a costume. The first generation, for all its technical inferiority, did not wear a costume. It was what it was.

There is also the price. The first FOiS can be found on the secondary market for significantly less than the new model, and for a certain kind of buyer, the value proposition matters more than the movement upgrade [citation:13]. The 1861 is not a bad movement. It is a reliable, serviceable, historically significant movement. The fact that it lacks a co-axial escapement and a silicon hairspring does not make it less capable of telling time, and telling time is, ostensibly, what a watch is for.

### The Suspense Neither Side Resolves

Here is the question that hangs over both generations: what is a tribute supposed to do? Is it supposed to recreate the object, or is it supposed to recreate the *experience* of the object? The first FOiS recreated the object—a Speedmaster with CK 2998 proportions and a black dial. The second FOiS attempts to recreate the experience—the warmth of aged lume, the subtle variation of a dial that has seen decades of light, the domed crystal that feels like acrylic but resists scratches like sapphire. The defenders of the second generation argue that the experience is what matters. The defenders of the first argue that the object is the only thing a watch can honestly be.

Neither side can claim a clean victory. The second generation is undeniably more sophisticated. The first generation is undeniably more sincere. The watch that would satisfy both—a technically modern Speedmaster with the restraint of the 2012 model and the historical fluency of the 2024 model—does not exist. That absence is the space where the argument lives.

## What the Comparison Reveals

Strip away the aesthetics and the movement debates, and the two FOiS generations are a study in how the watch industry has changed in twelve years. The 2012 watch was made in a moment when reissues were still relatively straightforward propositions. You took a vintage design, updated the materials, and called it a tribute. The 2024 watch is made in a moment when reissues are expected to be *curated*—to demonstrate a deep understanding of the original's quirks, variations, and historical contingencies. The OEM Watch Manufacturers that supply the industry have responded to this shift by producing materials and finishes that can simulate aging with a precision that would have been unimaginable a decade ago. The result is watches that are more historically informed and less historically honest.

Whether that is progress or regression depends on what you want from a watch. If you want the best possible object, the new FOiS is the answer. If you want an object that knows what it is and does not pretend otherwise, the old FOiS is the answer. The Custom Rose Gold Watches that dominate the upper reaches of the market have long understood that provenance and material can be manufactured, but sincerity cannot. The first FOiS was sincere. The second is sophisticated. The argument between them is not going to be settled by a specification sheet, because the specification sheet has already declared a winner. The argument is about whether the specification sheet is the right way to judge a tribute, and that is a question that only the wearer can answer.

Back to blog